hhmx.de

Anil Dash

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 17:36:13

This is a monumental day for the future of the social web, though it might not be obvious for a while. Mastodon matures its governance model with a great, solid non-profit blog.joinmastodon.org/2025/01/ and a coalition of independents push to open up Bluesky's AT Protocol: freeourfeeds.com/ These two moves together put the most credible players on solid ground for years to come — and set up the open platforms to enable lots of innovation just when it's needed most.

william.maggos

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 17:40:33

@anildash

$30m could do a lot more good growing and improving the fedi. fixing any problems that people have with it so far. ugh.

2xfo

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 17:43:15

@anildash
Why should we care about bluesky? I came here to get away from billionaires.

Anil Dash

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 17:53:14

@RnDanger Because it's an open, interoperable platform with millions of users and interesting apps being built on top of it

2xfo

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 18:02:46

@anildash
Sure, but it's a business ran by billionaires looking to make a profit. Why is a nonprofit concerned with them? What do they want there? I don't think fedi should be chasing billionaires to get their buy in because they will change the system to extract profit from the users.

And, I'm sorry, it doesn't help that I'm really suspicious of the nonprofit "social armor" effect after seeing ChatGPT and WordPress recently. It's hard not to assume individual profit and power motives are at play here more than anything else when billionaires are held up as valid actors in an independent space.

DoNotPunchDown

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 20:08:16

@RnDanger @anildash

I completely agree. I wondered how this place ran without ads. As soon as I registered, on an email I had no spam on, I have been suddenly receiving 10 or more spam emails a day.

I have gone without social media before. Not a problem to do it again. I came back from another server and I regret my new choices. This new blue sky thing, it's the antithetical to what the fediverse is supposed to be

2xfo

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 20:23:55

@DoNotPunchDown @anildash
I pay a small amount to support my instance and I've never seen spam from this place. (Edit: these facts are in no way related.)

Honestly, the more i learn about Mastodon.Social the more i want to defederate from it. I often wonder what the leaders there think Mastodon is for.

spinbackwards

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 18:49:12

@anildash @RnDanger Does AT support ActivityPub?

Magnus Ahltorp

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 19:13:38

@spinbackwards @anildash @RnDanger No. It has to be bridged.

Evan Prodromou

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 19:39:11

@ahltorp @spinbackwards @anildash @RnDanger We have a great bridge, though!

fed.brid.gy/

It's run by A New Social anew.social/

Magnus Ahltorp

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 19:55:11

@evan @spinbackwards @anildash @RnDanger Bridges are good when you can’t solve it any other way, but a bridge is like trying to look out the window, and instead of seeing the full 3D landscape, you see all the objects like they’re decals on the window.

If you go to the next window, there is another set of decals there. The tree-shaped decal on both windows represent the same tree in the outside world, but to you they look like two distinct objects. Because you can’t see out the window.

naught101

Föderation EN Di 14.01.2025 00:01:32

@anildash @RnDanger

It's not open and interoperable YET, right? And it's still owned by corporates, so there's a reasonable chance they will never come good on their promises..

stuart

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 18:50:47

@RnDanger @anildash

I came here to escape algorithms, ads and Elon. Some early Twitter escapees, notably the Guardian's Zoe Williams, found that here was boring and having to search for stuff rather than the platform deciding what you wanted was too hard. Hence they flew back and are probably now on BlueSky. I don't know because apart from the sketchy bridge thingy I can't see it unless I sign up there.

Extending ActivityHub & AT to interoperate gives us fhe best of worlds a choice of platform that best satisfies one's curated or non-curated needs but not at the expense of choosing the group of people you can interact with.

That's the what Fediverse was built for. At the instance or individual level to see all or just yourself.

Matt Wood

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 17:59:28

@anildash this is a weird comparison. Mastodon takes an actual action and this other thing writes an open letter?

Tim Bray

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 18:03:19

@anildash I'm a little cynical about announcements of fundraising *targets* but still, the important take-away is that a lot of people have noticed that social networking as a commercial product really doesn’t have an interesting future, it’s time to build out alternatives.

CartyBoston

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 18:59:01

@anildash I'd have liked them to wait to name the principals in the new org. "It's a nonprofit!" does not tell us very much yet.

Don Cruse

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 19:08:00

@anildash I’m glad someone is taking steps to build a second infrastructure (or at least relay) for Bluesky. It seems like a heavy lift. It’s striking that this group’s fundraising goal ($30mm) is about as much as Bluesky has raised itself.

Andrés Hirunatan

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 19:55:40

@anildash those are enormously great news! Thanks for sharing.

Jimmy Havok

Föderation EN Mo 13.01.2025 20:08:17

@anildash Fortune had an article today about that referenced Mastodon and ActivityPub at the end.