hhmx.de

Föderation EN Di 12.11.2024 22:15:27

I wish we'd stop spreading this misconception: "The most important way [Threads, Bluesky, and Mastodon] align is they all live on top of open, accessible protocols." augment.ink/bridges-the-last-n

Threads doesn't live on an open, accessible protocol. Its actual protocol is Instagram, which is proprietary. That's why, eleven months after Meta started testing federation—and eight months after it started letting fediverse users follow Threads accounts—you still can't follow a Mastodon account directly from Threads.

Föderation EN Di 12.11.2024 22:26:17

If/when Threads ends up federating more fully with Mastodon, it likely still won't be on AP, and unless it opens up Instagram, it won't live on an open, accessible protocol—it'll just bridge to one.

Recognizing that Meta is turning the openness of the fediverse into a sales pitch (and, arguably, a bait-and-switch), we should resist taking its marketing at face value and uncritically repeating claims like, "When Threads federates, I can move it to Mastodon or merge it into my existing Mastodon account while keeping the connections I made there, as long as they have federated." We can't be sure that Threads will actually adhere to that norm.

Föderation EN Di 12.11.2024 22:36:50

Seems like the idea that's taken hold since the US election is that we should be encouraging people to leave X-Twitter for any open alternative, with Threads included in that batch. But Threads isn't open yet. We shouldn't take Meta's word for it that it ever will be. Recommending that people migrate there might be setting them up for another platform enclosure. Staying on Twitter is likely worse, but given a choice, you're better off pointing them to services that allow migration and federation now, not just on some hypothetical roadmap.

Föderation EN Di 12.11.2024 22:43:05

"That's what a good tool does: it hides the complexities and lets the user focus on their end goal."

No. Absolutely not. A good tool may save you the trouble of having to engage complexity, but if it hides those complexities, then it is narrowing your ability to understand and your capacity to choose. Commercial social media platforms do that all the time, resulting in dark patterns that manufacture consent for things the user wouldn't knowingly choose if given the option in clear, equitable terms.